Irrlicht Engine

Is there a good free audio library that has 2D and 3D sound support and allows you to use in a commerical product without any restrictions. I know IrrKlang has those, but you have to pay a fee to use it in a commerical prdouct, so I was wondering if there was any free library avaiable, I know of audiere, but its mostly 2D

Well I recommend just using OpenAL directly, or OpenAL++. There is also CAudio, which can be found on this forum, and has bindings to Irrlicht I believe.

I use audiere, its easy to use and very helpful

Audiere has extant crash bugs on Windows (yes, yes, it works for you). CAudio is just a wrapper over OpenAL.

IrrKlang has the best combination of ease of use and stability that I've come across. If you're concerned about the cost, then you're valuing your time pretty cheaply. Since you don't have to pay until and unless you go commercial, you're also not showing a lot of confidence in your product.

Is all I'm saying.

rogerborg wrote:Audiere has extant crash bugs on Windows

Merely out of curiosity what crash bugs are you talking about, any specific examples?

I use SDL_mixer. It's simple and has all the features you need, even though it's written in C (but well written)

jam wrote:

rogerborg wrote:Audiere has extant crash bugs on Windows

Merely out of curiosity what crash bugs are you talking about, any specific examples?

This one, which was still extant last time I tried Audiere about 9 months ago. I had a quick look into it, but the cause wasn't immediately obvious, and I didn't feel much inclined to pour time down that hole since the Audiere devs are apparently so disinterested in the Windows version.

I still Audiere to be the best option for now, until another good free open source audio library comes along. Maybe I should start work on my own?